Supreme Court Dismisses Petition Seeking to Bar Three Judges From Hearing BBI Appeal Case

Bbi appeal
DCJ Philomena Mwilu. [Courtesy]

The Supreme Court on Tuesday dismissed an application seeking the recusal of three judges from hearing the BBI Appeal.

The petitioner, Isaac Aluochier, wanted Justices Njoki Ndungu, Smokin Wanjala and Mohammed Ibrahim to recuse themselves saying he had filed a petition before Judicial Service Commission (JSC) for their ouster.

Mr Aluochier argued that the matter before the court should be heard by an impartial bench.

He claimed that in 2016, he wrote to the JSC seeking the removal of Supreme Court judges led by former Chief Justice Willy Mutunga and Justices Phillip Tunoi, Jacktone Ojwang, Mohammed Ibrahim, Smokin Wanjala and Njoki Ndung’u.

Read: Petitioner Wants Three Supreme Court Judges Out of BBI Case Over Bias

He accused the judges of breach of code of conduct and gross misbehaviour.

But according to DCJ Philomena Mwilu the possibility of bias against the judges is far fetched and speculative.

“The applicant having instituted the petition before JSC it should be allowed to take its course since the commission is an independent body,” Justice Mwilu said.

“The notice of motion lacks in merit and is disallowed.”

The court has also allowed eight applications for amicii saying the submissions filed by the different amicus curie will help the court in reaching a determination.

Email your news TIPS to or WhatsApp +254708677607. You can also find us on Telegram through


Written by Eva Nyambura

Content creator at | Passionate about telling the untold story. Lover of life, music and technology. Simplicity is KEY


Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Facebook Reels

Facebook Ranks Top On List of Social Media Apps Used to Exploit Minors in Kenya – Report


Here’s a List of Wanted Terrorists with Sh50 Million Bounty on their Heads